IT CAN NEVER BE THE SAME
Language: English or Italian
Photography: Lorenzo Tugnoli
Text: Habib Zahori and Francesca Recchia
Design: GHOST
IT CAN NEVER BE THE SAME presents a body of work that spans from 2019 to 2023, during Afghanistan’s pivotal years of transition — from the US-Taliban peace talks to the collapse of the Afghan republic and, ultimately, the Taliban’s return to power.
The images depict a country in upheaval, as experienced by a foreign photographer who has spent over a decade navigating its complexities. This book is not a traditional reportage but a reflective journey. Through the ambiguity of photography, it explores how visual representations shape the perception of a complex country, its history, and the distance between those who tell the story and those who live it.
Tugnoli arrived in Afghanistan in 2009, where began working as a full-time photographer. He spent six years living in the country and then returned to it again and again. Through the years he travelled all over the country and learnt so much from its people.
After 2023, Tugnoli spent over a year reflecting on the photographs he had taken, shaping them into a body of work that seeks a more meditative tone. This process was driven by a growing interest in the relationship between images and the broader visual representation of Afghanistan, and developed in collaboration with researcher Francesca Recchia. As a photographer, Tugnoli was deeply inspired by the tradition of black and white photojournalism but he started asking himself whether he was photographing Afghanistan to recreate the familiar imagery, to emulate a movie that repeats itself on loop in my outsider’s head, or whether he was truly telling a story grounded in a deep sense of the place.
Afghanistan resists foreign understanding, and its image has been repeatedly appropriated and reshaped by the empires that have occupied it over the centuries. Misunderstandings arise not only from the difficulty of accessing the country’s many layers of meaning but also from a tendency on our part, as journalists, to simplify and misrepresent. These simplifications help build narratives that justify foreign wars and occupations, often carried out in the name of spreading democratic values and defending women’s rights.
The publication of this book is particularly important at a moment when foreign aid to Afghanistan has been severely cut, after decades of occupation and relentless bombing by foreign powers, and the country has, for the most part, disappeared from the headlines.










